Pedotransfer Functions for Estimating Soil Hydraulic Properties: A Review

doi:10.1016/S1002-0160(15)60054-6

Pedosphere

Volume 26, Issue 4, August 2016, Pages 417-430

https://doi.org/10.1016/S1002-0160(15)60054-6 Get rights and content

Abstract

Characterization of soil hydraulic properties is important to environment management; however, it is well recognized that it is laborious, time-consuming and expensive to directly measure soil hydraulic properties. This paper reviews the development of pedotransfer functions (PTFs) used as an alternative tool to estimate soil hydraulic properties during the last two decades. Modern soil survey techniques like satellite imagery/remote sensing has been used in developing PTFs. Compared to mechanistic approaches, empirical relationships between physical properties and hydraulic properties have received wide preference for predicting soil hydraulic properties. Many PTFs based on different parametric functions can be found in the literature. A number of researchers have pursued a universal function that can describe water retention characteristics of all types of soils, but no single function can be termed generic though van Genuchten (VG) function has been the most widely adopted. Most of the reported parametric PTFs focus on estimation of VG parameters to obtain water retention curve (WRC). A number of physical, morphological and chemical properties have been used as predictor variables in PTFs. Conventionally, regression algorithms/techniques (statistical/neural regression) have been used for calibrating PTFs. However, there are reports of utilizing data mining techniques, e.g., pattern recognition and genetic algorithm. It is inferred that it is critical to refine the data used for calibration to improve the accuracy and reliability of the PTFs. Many statistical indices, including root mean square error (RMSE), index of agreement (d), maximum absolute error (ME), mean absolute error (MAE), coefficient of determination (r²) and correlation coefficient (r), have been used by different researchers to evaluate and validate PTFs. It is argued that being location specific, research interest in PTFs will continue till generic PTFs are developed and validated. In future studies, improved methods will be required to extract information from the existing database.

References (84)

Y-D Botula et al.
Evaluation of pedotransfer functions for predicting water retention of soils in Lower Congo (D.R. Congo)
Agr Water Manage
(2012)
J C Dijkerman
An Ustult-Aquult-Tropept catena in Sierra Leone, West Africa, II. Land qualities and land evaluation
Geoderma
(1988)
A Espino et al.
Cautionary notes on the use of pedotransfer functions for estimating soil hydraulic properties
Agr Water Manage
(1996)
J Givi et al.
Evaluation of pedotransfer functions in predicting the soil water contents at field capacity and wilting point
Agr Water Manage
(2004)
M G Hodnett et al.
Marked differences between van Genuchten soil water-retention parameters for temperate and tropical soils: a new water-retention pedo-transfer function developed for tropical soils
Geoderma
(2002)
R B Jana et al.
Enhancing PTFs with remotely sensed data for multi-scale soil water retention estimation
J Hydrol
(2011)
R Lal
Physical properties and moisture retention characteristics of some Nigerian soils
Geoderma
(1978)
T Mayr et al.
Pedotransfer function to estimate soil water retention parameters for a modified Brooks-Corey type model
Geoderma
(1999)
A B McBratney et al.
From pedotransfer functions to soil inference systems
Geoderma
(2002)
B Minasny et al.
Comparison of different approaches to the development of pedotransfer functions for water-retention curves
Geoderma
(1999)

B Minasny et al.

Regression rules as a tool for predicting soil properties from infrared reflectance spectroscopy

Chemometr Intell Lab Syst

(2008)

B Minasny et al.

Predicting soil properties in the tropics

Earth-Sci Rev

(2011)

W J Rawls et al.

Testing soil water retention estimation with the MUUF pedotransfer model using data from the southern United States

J Hydrol

(2001)

N Romano et al.

Prediction of soil water retention using soil physical data and terrain attributes

J Hydrol

(2002)

O Salazar et al.

Evaluation of DRAIN-MOD using saturated hydraulic conductivity estimated by a pedotransfer function model

Agr Water Manage

(2008)

M G Schaap et al.

ROSETTA: a computer program for estimating soil hydraulic parameters with hierarchical pedotransfer functions

J Hydrol

(2001)

F Ungaro et al.

Using existing soil databases for estimating retention properties for soils of the Pinaura Padano-Veneta region of North Italy

Geoderma

(2001)

M van den Berg et al.

Pedotransfer functions for the estimation of moisture retention characteristics of Ferralsols and related soils

Geoderma

(1997)

B Wagner et al.

Evaluation of pedo-transfer functions for unsaturated soil hydraulic conductivity using an independent data set

Geoderma

(2001)

J H M Wösten et al.

Comparison of class and continuous pedotransfer functions to generate soil hydraulic characteristics

Geoderma

(1995)

J H M Wösten et al.

Development and use of a database of hydraulic properties of European soils

Geoderma

(1999)

J H M Wösten et al.

Pedotransfer functions: bridging the gap between available basic soil data and missing soil hydraulic characteristics

J Hydrol

(2001)

L R Ahuja et al.

Estimating soil water characteristics from simpler properties or limited data

Soil Sci Soc Am J

(1985)

P O Aina et al.

Estimating available water-holding capacity of western Nigerian soils from soil texture and bulk density, using core and sieved samples

Soil Sci Soc Am J

(1985)

C Alvarez-Acosta et al.

Test of the Rosetta pedotransfer function for saturated hydraulic conductivity

Open J Soil Sci

(2012)

F B Arruda et al.

Parámetros de solo para o càlculo da àgua disponível com base na textura do solo)

Rev Bras Ci Solo (in Spanish)

(1987)

L M Arya et al.

Scaling parameter to predict the soil water characteristic from particle-size distribution data

Soil Sci Soc Am J

(1999)

G W Bloemen

Calculation of hydraulic conductivities of soil from texture and organic matter content

Z Pflanzenernähr Bodenk (in German)

(1980)

J Bouma

Using soil survey data for quantitative land evaluation

Adv Soil Sci

(1989)

R H Brooks et al.

Properties of porous media affecting fluid flow

J Irrig Drain Div

(1966)

A Bruand et al.

Prediction of water retention properties of clayey soils: validity of relationships using a single soil characteristic

Soil Use Manage

(1994)

G S Campbell et al.

Prediction of hydraulic properties of soils using particle-size distribution and bulk density data

G S Campbell

A simple method for determining unsaturated conductivity from moisture retention data

Soil Sci

(1974)

A Canarache

Physical-technological maps. A possible product of soil survey for direct use in agriculture

Soil Technol

(1993)

P Carman

Fluid flow through a granular bed

Trans Inst Chem Eng

(1937)

P Carman

Flow of gases through porous media

(1956)

C Chen et al.

Measured and modeled unsaturated hydraulic conductivity of a Walla Walla silt loam

Soil Sci Soc Am J

(2001)

P M Driessen

The water balance of the soil

D A Farrel et al.

Modeling the pore structure of porous media

Water Resour Res

(1972)

F Gérard et al.

Preferential flow revealed by hydrologic modeling based on predicted hydraulic properties

Soil Sci Soc Am J

(2004)

A K Guber et al.

Multimodeling with Pedotransfer Functions

S C Gupta et al.

Estimating soil water retention characteristics from particle size distribution, organic matter percent, and bulk density

Water Resour Res

(1979)

Cited by (113)

Estimation of Infiltration Parameters: The Role of Pedotransfer Functions and Initial Moisture Conditions
2024, Journal of Hydrology
Infiltration is one of the key components of rainfall-runoff processes at small catchment scale and is therefore a vital component of hydrological models. However, small catchments typically lack direct infiltration measurements and associated soil hydraulic characteristics, which are being substituted with soil databases and pedotransfer functions built upon these databases. We utilized two sets of pedotransfer functions Rosetta 3 and EUPTFv2 derived from two well known soil databases: UNSODA, based on US and global soil data, and EU-HYDI, based on EU soil data. Our study evaluates the impact of choosing one of these pedotransfer functions on modeled infiltration in relation to variable initial moisture content- It investigates the behavior of the simplified infiltration models of Green-Ampt and Philip under different initial conditions, in comparison with Richards’ complex solution, which is used as a benchmark. Our evaluation was conducted using soil property data available in the Czech Republic, covering ten USDA soil textures that are prevalent within the European Union. The applied initial moisture conditions were derived for specific suction pressure values that correspond to hydrological initial conditions ranging from near saturation to near the permanent wilting point. Variation in the derived parameters for the Green-Ampt and Philip models across the pedotransfer function sources results in considerable variation in the modeled infiltration. Our results imply different sensitivities of the simplified infiltration models to the initial moisture for different pedotransfer functions. The Green-Ampt and Philip infiltration models demonstrate better alignment with Richards’ complex solution with a low and consistent RMSE when using the Rosetta 3 pedotransfer function. By contrast, the EUPTFv2 model scenarios, show a clear trend of increasing RMSE towards dry initial conditions. As the European soil database is not an open data source, we only hypothesize that the distributions of soil characteristics in the European soil database differ systematically from those in UNSODA, and that this would cause different results of pedotransfer functions for different initial moisture conditions. The findings of this study are important for selecting appropriate infiltration models and, appropriate pedotransfer functions for estimating model parameters, and for assessing uncertainties connected with varying initial conditions.
Effects of vegetation roots on the structure and hydraulic properties of soils: A perspective review
2024, Science of the Total Environment
This paper aims to provide a state-of-the-art review on the effects of vegetation roots on the soil structure and soil hydraulic properties. After a thorough review of current studies, the effects of vegetation roots are summarized into four: root exudation, root penetration, root water uptake and root decay. Root exudates alter the size and stability of aggregates, the contact angle of soil, and the viscosity and surface tension of pore fluid; root exudates of crops always increase the soil water retention capacity and decrease the soil saturated hydraulic conductivity. Root penetration creates new pores or clogs existing pores during root growth, and root parameters (e.g., root biomass density, root diameter and root length density) are well correlated to soil hydraulic properties. Root water uptake can apparently increase the soil water retention capacity by providing an additional negative pressure and induce micro-fissures and macropores in the rhizosphere soil. Root decay modifies the pore structure and water repellency of soil, resulting in the increase of soil macro-porosity, soil water retention, and the saturated hydraulic conductivity or steady infiltration rate. Some of the above four effects may be difficult to be distinguished, and most importantly each is highly time-dependent and influenced by a multitude of plant-related and soil-related factors. Therefore, it remains a significant challenge to comprehend and quantify the effects of vegetation roots on the soil structure and soil hydraulic properties. Unsolved questions and disputes that require further investigations in the future are summarized in this review.
Pedotransfer functions and machine learning: Advancements and challenges in tropical soils
2023, Geoderma Regional
Soil hydraulic properties (SHP) are crucial information for several Earth system applications and their availability strongly relies on pedotransfer functions (PTFs). In this review, we aimed to bring to light what was done in the period 2012–2021 regarding the modeling of SHP by PTFs. Data were collected from 101 publications, yielding information from 1844 different PTFs across the world. PTF development was analyzed regarding coverage/domain, predominant climate, countries, target variable, methods to derive PTF, algorithms used (in case of machine learning), predictors, model sensitivity and uncertainty assessment, number of samples for models training and testing, error metrics and goodness-of-fit criteria, among more. A significant contribution from tropical regions was observed, which was seldom in past studies. The increased use of machine learning techniques to build PTFs was also a remarkable result, although conventional regression still prevailed. Given the growth of machine learning techniques in recent years, we delve deeper into this discussion. Generally, machine learning-based PTFs provided lower errors than conventional PTFs and should be considered for future studies. As a case study, we evaluated existing PTFs to predict water retention and hydraulic conductivity of soils from an important tropical agricultural center, the Mato Grosso state in Brazil. Results reinforce the low ability of PTFs based on temperate soils data to predict SHP of tropical soils, especially concerning fine-textured soils. Nonetheless, PTFs based on tropical soils also showed modest performances, indicating that the seek for greater reliability of PTFs is still pursued. The most outstanding results were observed for fine-textured soils, for which all PTFs had poor performance. Overall, results corroborate that there is a special demand for developing PTFs capable of well recognizing the hydraulic patterns of fine-textured tropical soils.
Prediction of water retention properties of French soils using the in situ volumetric water content at field capacity as single input data
2023, Soil and Tillage Research
The objective of this study was to investigate the relevance of using the in situ volumetric water content at field capacity ( $θ_{FC}$ ) as a predictor of the water retention properties by comparing the performances of pedotransfer functions (PTFs) established using artificial neural networks (ANN-PTFs) and support vector machines (SVM-PTFs) with much simpler PTFs in the form of simple linear regressions (SLR-PTFs). A dataset comprising 456 horizons collected in soils located in France was used. The available data were: the silt and clay contents (SC), the organic carbon content (OC), the bulk density at field capacity ( ${BD}_{FC}^{m}$ ), the in situ gravimetric water content at field capacity ${(W}_{FC}^{m}$ ) related to $θ_{FC}$ by using ${BD}_{FC}^{m}$ , and the volumetric water content at –1, –3.3, –10, –33, –100, –330 and –1500 kPa matric potential. The performances of the PTFs studied were compared by using the root mean squared error (RMSE) and the coefficient of determination (R²). Our results showed the relevance of using $θ_{FC}$ , which was proved to be close to the volumetric water content at –10 kPa matric potential, as a predictor of the water retention properties. With ANN-PTFs, the best performances were recorded when both $θ_{FC}$ and SC were used as input data (RMSE = 0.027 cm³ cm^-3 and R² = 0.92). With SVM-PTFs, the smallest RMSE was recorded when $θ_{FC}$ was used as single input data (RMSE = 0.026 cm³ cm^-3). As for R² of SVM-PTFs, it was the highest with $θ_{FC}$ and SC as input data (R² = 0.84). The SLR-PTFs using $θ_{FC}$ as single predictor after stratification by texture performed better (RMSE = 0.031 cm³ cm^-3 and R² = 0.88) than the ANN-PTFs using one or two soil characteristics as input data. Comparison of SLR-PTFs with SVM-PTFs showed that the latter performed slightly better than SLR-PTFs after stratification by texture but R² was smaller when $θ_{FC}$ was used as the single predictor. Use of a predicted value of the bulk density at field capacity to obtain a value of in situ volumetric water content at field capacity led to poorer performances of the SLR-PTFs but after stratification by texture they remained close to those recorded with ANN-PTFs or SVM-PTFs when they used a single soil characteristic as input data. Finally, our results showed that associating OC to the input data did not increase the perfomances of the ANN-PTFs and SVM-PTFs.
Incorporating machine learning models and remote sensing to assess the spatial distribution of saturated hydraulic conductivity in a light-textured soil
2023, Computers and Electronics in Agriculture
Saturated soil hydraulic conductivity (K_sat) is a key component in hydrogeology and water management. This study aimed at evaluating popular tree-based machine learning algorithms (Random forest (RF), Quantile random forest (QRF), Cubist (Cu), and Decision tree regression (DTr)) to assess the spatial distribution of K_sat in a sandy agricultural field. Soil surface reflectance derived from Landsat-8 (OLI/TIRS) (several remotely sensed data including original surface reflectances of spectral bands and 22 remote sensing indices) as well as limited ground measured soil data were used as predictor covariates. Using collected disturbed and undisturbed soil samples, physicochemical properties (K_sat, porosity, organic matter, and texture contents) were determined. Based on novel supervised feature selection, covariates including Landsat-8 spectral Band2, Band4, Band6, and Band7, normalized difference pond index (NDPI), normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI), and silt content were identified as the most important factors in K_sat prediction. Variable importance analysis showed Band7 and Band6 were explaining 54% of the total K_sat variation. The model evaluation, using five statistics cretria, Taylor diagram and the Kruskal–Wallis (KW) test, demonstrates the outperformance of RF being followed by QRF, Cu, and DTr models. Accordingly, the RF method combined with an optimized sampling approach provides the most accurate digital soil K_sat map. The uncertainty analysis showed no significant different trend in K_sat predictions by applying more dense datasets confirming original-limited data (n = 28) was efficient and sufficient to derive a reliable K_sat-map. The developed approach, which can be scaled up at a large scale, seems to be useful in modelling water flow and solute transport for water and nutrient management purposes toward precision agriculture.
Organization of the soil profile controls the risks of runoff in the humid Ethiopian Highlands
2023, Journal of Hydrology
Citation Excerpt :
Two instruments were used to develop the WRCs at University of California, Berkeley: the Hyprop instrument and the WP4C dew point potential meter. The Hyprop uses an evaporation method with precision tensiometers (Schindler, 1980; Peters and Durner, 2008; Schindler et al., 2010b,a) to measure soil water potential, and soil volumetric water content is determined from gravimetric water content. Following the Hyprop measurements, we took 7 ml disturbed soil from the intact soil samples for use in the WP4C instrument and measurements of the dry end of the water retention curve.
Erosion of agricultural land endangers the livelihood of millions of people who depend on natural resources. Soil and water conservation practices (SWCP) are intended to reduce runoff production and erosion. Understanding surface runoff drivers are crucial for the effective design and implementation of SWCPs. We present field observations of complex vertical soil profiles and variations in lithology along hillslopes ridge-channel transects from the Debre Mawi watershed in the upper Abay (Blue Nile) basin of the Ethiopian Highlands. Our study generates the first depth- and hillslope-distributed soil water retention curves, textural profiles and measures of hydraulic conductivity for the region. We provide guidance into preferred pedotransfer functions (PTFs) and their sensitivity to clay fraction. Hydrological processes associated with the observed vertical profiles and variations on them were simulated with the Hydrus-2D software package, revealing that dominant runoff generation mechanisms were sensitive to the vertical organization of soil texture, particularly at depths of 30 cm or more below the soil surface for soil profiles that have well-drained surface soil textures. This suggests that current practices of evaluating soil properties based on surface texture only is insufficient for understanding hillslope hydrology and mitigating soil erosion in these regions. In regions where comprehensive soil hydraulic profile data is not available, our study quantifies the uncertainties in both PTFs and hydrological fluxes due to variation of soil profile texture present; these can aid decision makers in data collection and accounting of errors for the intended application of interest.

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text